A federal judge on Monday dismissed a lawsuit seeking to void President Donald Trump’s decision to cap a popular tax break for filers in high-tax states as part of the 2017 tax overhaul.
U.S. District Judge Paul Oetken in Manhattan said New York, Connecticut, Maryland and New Jersey failed to show that the $10,000 cap on federal deductions for state and local taxes exceeded Congress’ constitutional power to levy income taxes.
He also found no basis to conclude that the so-called SALT cap was an effort to coerce states through “economic dragooning” into lowering their own taxes and cutting services, in line with the federal government’s own policy preferences.
Big ups to U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken for using, like, plain English in his ruling striking down New York’s SALT cap lawsuit.https://t.co/TYded79FpV pic.twitter.com/VTl7hM72zn
— Jon Campbell (@JonCampbellGAN) September 30, 2019
The states failed to show that the cap “puts them to the forced choice of lowering tax rates or facing budgetary catastrophe,” Oetken wrote.
Oetken’s decision is a victory for Trump, who used the cap to help pay for other parts of his $1.5 trillion tax overhaul, which included cutting taxes for wealthy Americans and slashing the corporate tax rate.
The cap affects people mainly in Democratic-leaning states such as California and the four states that brought the lawsuit in July 2018. Trump is a Republican, and Congress was controlled by Republicans in 2017.
Representatives for New York Governor Andrew Cuomo and Attorney General Letitia James did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The U.S. Department of Justice did not immediately respond to a similar request.
Should the deduction the IRS allows for state taxes be capped?
The cap allows individuals and married taxpayers filing jointly who itemize deductions to deduct only up to $10,000 annually for state and local income, property and sales taxes. Married individuals filing separately are capped at $5,000.
States opposed to the cap said it would depress home prices, spending, jobs and economic growth and make it harder to pay for hospitals, police, schools, and road and bridge construction and maintenance.
New York said the average SALT deduction claimed by 3.3 million residents who itemized their deductions on their federal returns was $21,943 in 2015.
In February, the administration estimated that the cap would have left 10.9 million filers unable to deduct $323.1 billion in state and local taxes from their 2018 returns.
Some states have proposed means to let taxpayers classify some tax payments as charitable contributions, which are not subject to the cap. The Treasury Department and Internal Revenue Service have warned against such workarounds.
Reuters contributed to this report.
Facebook has greatly reduced the distribution of our stories in our readers’ newsfeeds and is instead promoting mainstream media sources. When you share to your friends, however, you greatly help distribute our content. Please take a moment and consider sharing this article with your friends and family. Thank you.